It’s been a debate that’s raged since the ’60s, but finally there is a definitive Beatles Vs. Stones book (October 29, Simon & Schuster). As there is no singular definitive book that spans The Rolling Stones‘ entire career and there are too many books over 500 pages that cover the every move of The Beatles, so this kind of side-by-side comparison is something you’d have to read at least a dozen books on both bands to cobble together yourself. Author John McMillian did that and more, reading alternative newspapers, teen magazine interviews and underground manifestos from the ’60s to get a sense of what people were really saying about the bands — and what the bands were really saying.

Hardcore fans of either band will be at least tangentially aware of many of the points of comparison addressed by McMillian. But the author, who is an expert on American radicalism and has written another ’60s-focused book, Smoking Typewriters: The Sixties Underground Press and the Rise of Alternative Media in America, tackles one aspect of the Beatles vs. Stones debate you rarely see addressed: their political activism vs. the public’s perception of it. Fans know the good boys vs. bad boys marketing mythology around the two bands (and how inaccurate it was, especially in the early ’60s), but what is often forgotten as the decades have passed are their divergent identifications with the more uplifting vs. more violent aspects of radical youth culture in the later ’60s.

At the end of that decade, the world was presented with a lovey-dovey image of The Beatles, whose major political force was a not-yet-publicly-progressive John Lennon. The Stones, meanwhile, were branded as more radical in their political views, with less “peace and love” and more “destroy the The Man using necessary force.” It’s the good vs. bad, or rather Establishment vs. Anti-Establishment, narrative all over again. But the reality of their political action is much more bland than fans would admit.

“In 1968 there was this big debate [in radical American underground newspapers]…between Beatles and Stones fans about which group had the right political analysis,” McMillan tells “The Beatles were associated with the aesthetic radicalism of the counterculture — and the hippies, and peace and love. The Stones would be associated with the street fighting ethic of the New Left — the politics of confrontation against the police.”

McMillian went on to detail the evolution of The Beatles’ political narratives, starting with “The Word” on 1965’s Rubber Soul (where they used the word “love” in the hippie sense, as a lean-back approach to fixing the world) to the overt political message of Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band. But the watershed political moment came for the band when they released “Revolution” in 1968.

“That song was basically a put-down of the New Left militants: the people who were into fighting the police and breaking windows and whatever else,” McMillian explained. “By 1968, so much had happened politically to radicalize and galvanize young people that a lot of people were put off by The Beatles. A lot of their fans were put off by what they thought was a weak political analysis.”

Some of those things McMillian refers to in 1968 include the assassinations of Martin Luther King, Jr. and Robert Kennedy, massive and violent riots at the Democratic National Convention in Chicago, and an increased number of protests against the Vietnam War (including massive student demonstrations and riots across the U.S. and Europe). While Lennon was still espousing lyrics about “freeing your mind instead,” the youth movement had moved beyond the hippie-dippie, free love stuff and into certifiable action. Lennon was left looking behind the times.


— Courtney E Smith,

(Disclosure: This book’s publisher, Simon & Schuster, is owned by CBS Corp. as is


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Listen Live